The recently published History
of the Mirrer Yeshivah by Dr. Lester
Eckman, a professor of history at Touro College and
a noted expert in the Musar movement, is the first
extended treatise of this subject in the English language.
Written in a lively, readable and fast moving style,
this slender volume rapidly covers the entire history
of the Mir Yeshiva from its foundations in 1815 by
Samuel Tiktinski up until its nominal end in Shanghai
in 1945.
Although
the known source material to document this fascinating
history is rather meager and Dr. Eckstein has chosen
to rely almost exclusively on one account only (1),
nonetheless this work manages to represent fairly adequately
the general development and evolution of the Mir Yeshiva
from its rudimentary origins as a preparatory academy
of local importance to a world renowned institution
of higher learning in its last period.
The various
controversies and power struggles which inevitably
arose in the long administration of the Yeshiva and
its sometimes contentious relations with the community
of Mir are touched upon. The forceful and inspiring personalities
of the Yeshiva's more eminent leaders in various periods
are also brought to light. As a sort of explanatory appendix
to this history, Dr. Eckman has judiciously added his
own brief summaries of some representative moral teachings
of three prominent figures from the Mir Yeshiva to better
connote the style of thinking and teaching to those unfamiliar
with this world.
Despite some of the shortcomings and
limitations I note in the second part of this review,
the author must be strongly commended for this noble
undertaking to bring to a wider readership an important
history which up to the present has remained largely
obscured in scattered, out of print sources mainly
in Hebrew. As such it is incumbent upon all those keenly
interested in the preservation of this history for
future generations to purchase copies of Dr. Eckman's
latest book. It is available in some select Jewish
bookstores on the East Coast or directly from the author's
own Judaic Research Institute (C/O of Dr. Lester Eckman,
747 Livingston Road, Elizabeth, NJ 07208-1352).
What may perhaps be deemed the author's
greatest strength, his close intimacy and strong personal
sympathy for the subject matter also paradoxically proves
to be the main limitation of this work. By adopting a "reverential" perspective
to the old Mir Yeshiva, Dr. Eckman relies too exclusively
for his whole account on a single essay (2) by the late
Rabbi Joseph David Epstein, himself a student of Mir,
a leading exponent of Musar teaching and an inspirational
mentor and first cousin of Dr. Eckman's, to whom this
book is partly dedicated.
The signal fault and limitation
of largely summarizing in English Rabbi Epstein's account
is that in many places there is a notable lack of depth
and detail to this thumbnail sketch of the Yeshiva's
history. Largely missing, for example, are revealing
excerpts from Yiddish and Hebrew memoirs of former students
of the Mir Yeshiva which provide a firsthand sense of
life at the academy in different periods. Those in quest
of excerpts from such memoirs of the Mir Yeshiva are
referred to the fundamental Hebrew work on this topic
by the late Moshe Zinowitz (2), a work Dr. Eckman cites
in his bibliography but apparently did not consult or
utilize extensively.
For example, the following account
of boarding at the Mir Yeshiva in the 1850s, which is
perhaps as overly critical as many other accounts seem
unrealistically idealized, might have been added for
some much needed objective contrast:
"Study usually began
at six o'clock in the morning and lasted until eight.
Morning prayers, attended by townsmen, took place from
eight to nine; breakfast was from nine to ten; chanting
the Talmud again from ten to twelve; the lesson by the
teacher began at noon and lasted usually until two in
the afternoon; dinner and rest was from two to four;
group reading from four to six; prayers from six to seven;
group reading from seven to nine and, finally, evening
prayers and rest; thus, day in and day out.
Anyone can
easily imagine the exhaustion of students by this regime;
especially taking into account the overcrowding, the
stuffiness and the undernourishment! It is not surprising
that almost all of the students of the Mir Yeshiva were
exhausted, pale and anemic, somehow timid and overwhelmed
by the oppressive assistant to the Rabbi, a strict instructor,
who inspected the school daily taking care that students
did not engage in frivolous conversations but were chanting
the Talmud." (4)
There are various other points of mystery,
confusion or omission in the History of the
Mirrer Yeshivah which result most likely
from the primary dependence on the one essay by Rabbi
Epstein. This is particularly the case in the last part
of the narrative history in Shanghai which has many Byzantine
complications and intrigues that would not necessarily
be clear to someone not previously intimately familiar
with certain personalities and details of this miraculous
rescue.
In the 130 year span of this history, some famous
alumni of the Mir Yeshiva are mentioned by Dr. Eckman
and somewhat detailed, as well as others in passing who
supported the institution in various ways. However, a
great number of well-known graduates of the Mir Yeshiva
are inexplicably unaccounted for and there is no evident
logic or pattern as to why certain persons are briefly
listed while very many others are completely omitted
including some famous authors, leading Zionist activists
and future leaders of Israel (5).
The index of names
is a useful addition and reference even to so brief a
work. However, even here, the casual reader or researcher
looking only for references to a particular person must
exercise due caution as the index only covers references
to complete names and more often than not a rabbi will
appear familiarly as, for example, "Rabbi
Chaim Ozer" rather than "Rabbi Chaim Ozer Grodzensky".
Finally, the work could have benefited greatly from more
careful English proofreading and editing of syntax. Occasionally,
there are some comical transpositions of letters, such
as on p. 118 where three times "martial
law" appears where "marital law" was meant: "From 'within'
however, martial law consists of trust, companionship
and partnership." As Dr. Eckman projects writing in rapid
succession the histories of all the major yeshivot in
Eastern Europe, of which the History of the
Mirrer Yeshivah is
but the first installment, it is to be earnestly hoped
that forthcoming volumes will utilize a much more extensive
set of sources, will provide greater detail and depth
and will be more carefully edited. Some of Dr. Eckman's
previous work, including the highly respected biography
of the Hafets Hayyim, Revered by All ,
is an example of serious scholarship which would be a
fine model to emulate in forthcoming volumes on the history
of other Eastern European yeshivot.
Patrick Gordis
Berkeley, CA
USA
(1) As Dr. Eckman himself notes, "This work on the history
of the Mirrer Yeshivah is based primarily on the erudite
information provided by Rabbi J.D. Epstein in the above
mentioned work." (p. 31).
(2) Epstein, J.D. In Jewish Institutions
of Higher Learning in Europe: Their Development and
Destruction [in Hebrew], S. K. Mirsky
ed., New York, 1956.
(3) Zinowitz (i.e., Tzinovitz),
Moshe. Mir: Toldot
Yeshivat Mir . Tel Aviv, 1980. The
further subtitle of this book, "moreha, hayeha, talmideha,
ve-toratah" indicates the wider scope of its historiography.
(4) Kovner, Abraham Uri (1842-1909), Notes
of a Jew [in Russian], Istoricheskii
Viestnik , v. 91 (1903), p. 993 (for
the whole Mir Yeshiva account see pages 990-997).
The reviewer has a complete English translation
of this available upon request.
(5) Toldot Yeshivat Mir ,
cited above, though by no means comprehensive, provides
a much wider range of short biographies of notable
graduates and faculty of the Mir Yeshiva.
|