Project Report:
Flexibility Training Program
Barry T. Bates, Ph.D.
John A. Mercer, Ph.D.
Alan W. Arata, Ph.D..
Department of Exercise and Movement Science
University of Oregon
Eugene, OR 97403-1240
Project Summary
The use of the Precor
Stretch Trainer significantly improved performance
on the SAR test after 30 days of flexibility training. Subjects also
significantly improved performance on the Backstretch and Hamstring
stretch, but not on the Butterfly stretch due to the greater subject
variability. The results indicated an interrelationship among the
stretches as should be expected. The greatest improvements were shown by
males (vs females), individuals not involved in a stretch program prior
to
this program, those with low exercise levels and individuals exhibiting
moderate flexibility at the onset of the stretching program. Age and
stature were only moderately related to improvement.
Purpose
The purpose of this project was to evaluate improved flexibility as a
result of a 30 day stretching program using the Stretch Trainer.
Methods
Thirty-one subjects (age: 43.5 17.4 years, range: 36 - 61.2; mass: 73
114 kg; stature: 1.7 10.1 m) volunteered to complete a 30 day flexibility
training study. An additional 10 subjects volunteered to participate in
the study as a control group. The subjects were all selected from the
Eugene/Springfield area. All subjects were asked to maintain their
initial activity level during the 30 day stretching program. In addition,
all subjects were to complete the Stretch Trainer program (all stretches)
at least 5 days per week. Prior to and at the completion of the program,
subjects were asked to complete a general questionnaire about their fitness program, including
stretching.
Flexibility was measured prior to and following the 30 day flexibility
training program. In order to assess flexibility, subjects completed a
"Sit-and-Reach" (SAR) test. Additionally, to determine if the Stretch
Trainer improved flexibility of specific muscle groups, the performances
of three stretches were measured while the subjects were using the Stretch
Trainer. The three stretches were the Back Stretch, Hamstring Stretch
(both left and right sides), and the Butterfly Stretch. The training
program required subjects to use the Stretch Trainer (Precor) as the mode
of stretching. Flexibility of the control group was assessed twice, with
each test session separated by 21-33 days.
The SAR was performed using a standard sit and reach box (Novel Products
Inc., Addison, IL). Subjects placed their feet flat against the box
(without shoes), kept knees straight, and with the right hand over the
left, reached as far as they could on a "4-count." The SAR score
represents the distance the person reached forward relative to his/her
feet while sitting. A score above 23 cm indicates that the person was
able to reach beyond his/her feet, and a score below 23 cm indicates that
the individual could not touch his/her toes. Each subject performed the
SAR test three times, and the average of the three scores was used in the
analysis.
After completing the SAR tests, each subject performed the three stretches
on the Stretch Trainer. Subjects were required to use the upper bar for
testing purposes and to keep the legs up against the pads during all
stretches where appropriate. To measure performance during the stretches,
a tape measure was attached on the seat column and a horizontal straight
edge was positioned on the handlebar column. The measurement between the
seat column and the handle bar column (i.e. straight edge) represented
the distance that the subject could stretch backwards. Measurements were
recorded during the 4th and 5th repetitions (of 6 reps). Following the 3
stretches on the Stretch Trainer, the subject was retested on the SAR
following the same procedures outlined above.
Training Program
The training group was required to complete the flexibility training
program using the Stretch Trainer program at least once per day, 5 days
per week. Subjects were instructed to perform six repetitions of each
stretch, and to go through all stretches at least once. Subjects were
also instructed to hold each stretch (i.e. repetition) for 3 seconds. If
the subjects desired to perform additional stretches, they were allowed
to do so. Subjects were required to record their stretching activity
daily in a Training Log.
The Stretch Trainer program consisted of 8 different stretches using a
machine (the "Stretch Trainer") designed to increase flexibility. The
stretches focused on increasing hamstring, lower back, and upper back
flexibility. It was stressed to all subjects that the stretches should
not be painful, and if there was every any sharp pain, that the stretching
should be discontinued. Subjects were given written instructions as well as the corporate video
instructions to use as needed.
(Specific subject instructions are detailed in
Appendix A). In
addition, subjects were personally instructed on the proper way to
perform each stretch before the program started and were further evaluated
and instructed on technique after the first week of the program. All
subjects were given a Stretch Trainer to use in their homes to maximize
compliance.
Results/Discussion
All 31 subjects completed the flexibility training program. One subject
(subject 1) did experience a muscle strain during the training program and
missed 3 days. However, he was able to resume stretching (his post test
SAR score improved more than the average) therefore his data were included
in the analysis.
The mean and standard deviation values for the group Sit And Reach (SAR)
difference scores as well as selected subgroup values are presented in
Table 1 and
Figure 1.
Individual subject improvement scores as a function
of initial flexibility are shown in
Figure 2. The group SAR score improved
significantly following the 30 day Precor Stretch Trainer program
(F(1,21)=39.784, p<.001). The males showed a greater improvement on the
SAR test than the females (F(1,21)=8.572, p=.008). The moderate stretch
and low exercise subgroups exhibited greater improvements than the other
comparative groups.
To determine if a subject's initial flexibility was an influencing factor
on improvement, subjects were classified as having poor, moderate, or high
flexibility at the beginning of the program. The criteria for grouping
subjects was based on the pre SAR score. Subjects who were grouped as
having poor flexibility had scores of less then 16 cm, moderate
flexibility between 16 and 30 cm, and high flexibility over 30 cm. A
score of 23 cm on the SAR indicated that a subject could touch his/her
toes. The mean and standard deviation values for improvement on the SAR
test for each of the flexibility groups are given in Table 2.
The data
indicate that the Moderate group showed the greatest improvement followed
by the Poor and High groups.
The mean difference scores for the specific individual stretches are given
in Table 3. Both the
Backstretch (t(30)=5.552, p<.001) and
Hamstring
(t(30)=3.227, p=.003) stretches improved significantly while the Butterfly
stretch did not show significant improvement (t(30)=.162, p=.872). The
relationship among these three sets of test scores and the SAR scores were
investigated using Pearson Product Moment Correlations (Table
4). The
differences between the Post and Pre Hamstring stretches was significantly
correlated with the difference between the Post and Pre SAR scores
(r=0.468, p=0.008). In contrast, the difference between the Post and Pre
Backstretch and Butterfly measures did not correlate with the SAR
(r=-0.003, p=.987; r=0.285, p=.120). Several other data sets were also
significantly correlated as shown in Table 4. These results
indicate that
there is an interrelationship among a number of the stretches as should be
expected.
The correlation coefficients among the variables of age, level of
flexibility, stature, pre SAR score, and improvement on the SAR test are
given in Table 5.
Flexibility was highly correlated with the
pre SAR
score, as should be expected. Also, the pre SAR was significantly
correlated with improvement on the SAR test, though the correlation was
quite low (r=-0.396, p<.05). Age and initial flexibility were negatively
correlated (r=-.361, p<.05) indicating a general decrease in flexibility
with age. There were no other significant correlations. Interestingly,
the correlation between the level of flexibility and improvement was
negatively correlated (but not significant), indicating that as a
subject's initial level of flexibility increased, improvement decreased.
To further explore this relationship, a one-way ANOVA was calculated with
the dependent variable being SAR improvement, and level of flexibility the
independent variable. The test indicated that the level of flexibility
was a significant factor (F(2,28)=11.44, p<.001) in determining the level
of improvement on the SAR. The moderately flexible group improved
significantly more on the SAR test compared to either the poor or high
flexibility groups. The relationship between the three levels of
flexibility and level of improvement is illustrated in the last three bars
in Figure 1.
Additional Figures
Figure 3 illustrates
the observed improvement in the SAR
Test vs Age while Figure 4
illustrates the observed
improvement in the SAR Test vs Stature. In these figures, a line of reference is plotted. Any
point on the
line of reference indicates that that subject showed no improvement, while
points above the line indicate an improvement.
Summary
The use of the Precor Stretch Trainer significantly improved performance on the SAR test after
30 days of flexibility training. Subjects also significantly improved performance on the
Backstretch and Hamstring stretch, but not on the Butterfly stretch due to the greater subject
variability. The results indicated an interrelationship among the stretches as should be expected.
The greatest improvements were shown by males (vs females), individuals not involved in a
stretch program prior to this program, those with low exercise levels and individuals exhibiting
moderate flexibility at the onset of the stretching program. Age and stature were only moderately
related to improvement.
Link to: